Christmas Toy Guide

From Christmas Past to Christmas Present

Vintage illustration of Santa Claus smoking a pipeVintage illustration of a decorated Christmas tree with toys and presents

Plush

Every plush toy we've written about, from the 1950s to today.

Plush listings

4 toys

Beanie Babies illustration

Beanie Babies

1990s · Plush

Pick your favorites and start collecting! Beanie Babies turned little stuffed animals in…

Read More
Squishmallows illustration

Squishmallows

2020s · Plush

Soft, squishy and collectible! Pick your favorite from thousands of Squishmallows charact…

Read More
Tickle Me Elmo illustration

Tickle Me Elmo

1990s · Plush

Give him a tickle and watch him laugh! Tickle Me Elmo was the must-have Christmas toy of…

Read More
Webkinz illustration

Webkinz

2000s · Plush

A cuddly companion with a special adoption code opened the door to a virtual world of pet…

Read More